In any sort of film, setting the tone is so important and what I love most about this film is that the tone is set right away with a simple exchange. And it's done in such a natural way, as if things are always like that, which leads you to believe that this world we're watching is pretty screwbally. You know this from the fact that when the young orphan girl says, "Yes ma'am," she curtsies at the same time; she's not being disrespectful, quite the contrary. In fact this serves to let the audience know that if anything, things may be backwards from here on out. This setting of tone isn't done late in the game, but instead it's done right away, especially after the whole view of the orphanage and the girls. It allows you to sit back and relax and watch the film, knowing exactly what kind of story will be told.
Our screwball heroine is Luisa Ginglebuscher, as played by Margaret Sullavan. I can't imagine someone else playing Luisa the way Sullavan does, with the star-struck eyes she flashes in this new world she's in outside of the orphanage. William Wyler used a lot of close-ups of Sullavan in this film, which apparently the studio wasn't too happy about, but I think that Wyler was wise in doing this, whether it was out of lovesickness or his actual cinematic vision. Seeing Luisa's reaction to being in the party at Detlaff's hotel or while she's in the theatre is exactly what we need to fall in love with her. Luisa isn't the wise-cracking or quick-witted heroines typical of the genre; she's innocent, but not in an irritating way. In fact, her simplicity at getting out of reach from the men who are after her is to tell them she's married. And when they question the veracity of her statement, she scrambles at trying to find an unsuspecting "husband." So while she's a different type of screwball heroine, she still sets up a ridiculous situation that turns screwy and in the end falls in love with the hero.
Herbert Marshall as the hero Dr Sporum doesn't come in until halfway through and when he's finally introduced he is a bearded fellow who appears stuffy and not too friendly. And while Luisa is the lead character of the film, it is Dr Sporum who undergoes the transformation in the film, changing into a happier man who turns generous with his newfound success. Of course, what he doesn't realize until the end is that the real change is because he's fallen in love.
The late introduction of Dr Sporum is one I don't really understand, but it works. What I assume happened was that the banter, which occurred mostly between Detlaff and Konrad, elongated the first half of the film. It's perhaps one of the strangest things to see in film, for your hero to come in so late, but in the second half of the film, Marshall is in almost all the scenes. The story was divided neatly so that the second half's pure focus is on Marshall and his newfound fortune.
The supporting cast was not just wonderful to watch, but their roles were written brilliantly. One of the things I enjoyed most is that Preston Sturges made the supporting cast say things that matter. This is especially true of the bit players, such as Beulah Bondi, Alan Hale, and Eric Blore. They're on screen for such little time but when they're on, they're memorable. I can imagine that as an actor, they must've appreciated that. Then there's Frank Morgan and Reginald Owen, who are great at fighting back and forth. Owen, as I've mentioned previously, steals the show, proving to be the true Good Fairy in my opinion. All of these characters serve a purpose, even if it is to make you laugh, which in this genre is quite important.
The pace is something I never really noticed too much in this film. This is probably because I was that entertained watching it. When Marshall finally came on screen I knew the film was halfway through and I couldn't believe it. I think the dialogue and the laughs that come out of it helps the pace move along, it keeps you involved in the film so that you don't notice that almost two hours have passed by once the film is done. And if you really think about, scenes are dragged out, but mostly for laughs. Otherwise, is it important to see someone order food? At the same time, this scene doesn't just create laughs, but it also creates tension. Detlaff wants to get Luisa out of Konrad's private room and it just isn't happening. In this, Sturges is brilliant in writing a scene that serves two purposes.
The Good Fairy is quite a silly movie that will have you laughing along the way. The fact that it's different from other films of the same genre, even today, is what makes this a stand-out from others. It's refreshing to watch something and at the very least it's not the same cookie-cutter film. Its strong point is, as mentioned before, the script, which Sturges wrote wonderfully. But Wyler takes credit too in being wise about not changing the film to something completely different and understanding what Sturges wrote. Wyler uses some great moments with Sullavan to show visual storytelling, and he gets memorable performances out of a great cast. It's a complete shame, though, that The Good Fairy has been forgotten. It's an absolute hidden gem that will have you laughing in no time.